Checklist when Switching to HTTPS


This is a memo before I switched all my services to https.

User Experience

Browser support: can users still view my site?

  • most browser support TLS 1.0 and up.
  • The only reason to enable SSL would be IE6 users /bless.

Content: (if https is supported at all) will users still see complete content?

This relates to how browser handles mixed content, the non-https resources in a https page.

  • active mixed content (e.g. <script src=) are blocked by most browsers
    • FX 23 +
    • IE 9 +
    • Chrome
  • passive mixed content (e.g. <img src=)
    • <img> loads with warning

Cost and Performance

Will server experience high load and explode?

Breakdown of SSL overhead

The extra stuff browser and server have to do includes:

  • Session Establishment
    • the part where client and server determines a encryption key for data transfer
    • once per SSL session
      • Some webservers support reuse of ssl session. nginx does.
    • cipher negotiation (cipher suite)
    • asymmetric encryption, typically RSA
      • simple benchmark: openssl speed rsa
  • After established: client and server exchange encrypted data
    • the part where client and server flows encrypted data to each other
    • symmetric encryption, typically AES
      • nowdays CPUs have intrustion set to accelerate this
      • simple benchmark: openssl speed aes

A good illustration of SSL: ssl-tls-handshake-overview

Estimation of overhead

We can use openssl speed rsa aes to estimate intensity and throughput of a server. In my $5 vultr instance (1cpu / 1G mem / AES-NI supported), I am getting this result:

type             16 bytes     64 bytes    256 bytes   1024 bytes   8192 bytes
aes-128 cbc      92395.92k   101214.20k   102269.63k   227764.25k   226313.75k
aes-192 cbc      76020.25k    83423.61k    85446.95k   191443.81k   192688.75k
aes-256 cbc      67800.93k    71916.01k    72710.14k   159391.21k   165057.65k

                  sign    verify    sign/s verify/s
rsa  512 bits 0.000070s 0.000005s  14302.2 203856.8
rsa 1024 bits 0.000193s 0.000013s   5183.6  79046.3
rsa 2048 bits 0.000908s 0.000040s   1101.7  25136.7
rsa 4096 bits 0.009625s 0.000149s    103.9   6691.5

That means for my small-to-medium traffic sites, SSL overhead is not likely to exceed around 10% of CPU.

Tools

References